What To Consider When Choosing Between a Tub and a Walk-In Shower

One of the most common questions people ask bathroom remodeling experts is, “Should I install a walk-in shower or a bathtub?” The bathtub vs. walk-in shower debate has no universal winner. Instead, homeowners have to consider the pros and cons to find the right choice for them. 

Five Factors That Can Help You Choose the Right Feature for Your Bathroom Renovation

How can you tell whether a bathtub or a walk-in shower is best for you? Take a look at some key factors that may influence your decision. 

1. Space Optimization

Perhaps you have a tub in your bathroom and want to renovate because the current setup is too cramped. Unless contractors take down walls and expand the space, the bathroom will continue to feel tight if you stick with a tub. Installing a shower could make the room feel much larger.

2. Accessibility

Think about how your remodeling project will serve you long-term. Choosing a bathtub vs. a walk-in shower shouldn’t be a decision you make lightly, since your mobility may change over time.

Do you plan on aging in place? Will your household eventually include children or older adults? Accessibility challenges may arise, which can make bathing difficult. 

Tubs could be the better choice for children, while aging seniors may benefit from a shower with a bench or handrails. 

3. Water Efficiency

Bathing is an essential activity, but it can quickly turn costly depending on how much water your household uses. Perhaps you’re remodeling your bathroom to make it more eco-friendly. Low-flush toilets and motion-activated sink faucets can help cut down your water consumption, but what about other plumbing features?

Walk-in showers tend to use significantly less water than bathtubs. If your goal is water efficiency, you can’t go wrong with adding a walk-in shower to your bathroom. 

4. Resale Value

If you sell your home, will buyers be happy with your remodeling choices? Opting for a bathtub vs. a walk-in shower could affect your property’s resale value. Buyers may prefer one feature over the other and could potentially make a higher offer if the house includes everything on their wishlist. 

5. Overall Comfort and Personal Preferences

There are advantages to considering what prospective buyers may think of your bathroom. However, the decision ultimately boils down to your personal preferences. 

Maybe you love the relaxation of soaking in a bubble bath. If you can’t part with this spa-like environment, feel free to install a shower/tub combination in your bathroom. 

On the other hand, you might be someone who never takes baths. There’s nothing wrong with choosing a walk-in shower if it better suits your lifestyle. 

Reimagine Your Bathroom With Pro Remodeling

What are the pros and cons of a bathtub vs. a walk-in shower? What is the average bathroom remodel timeline? How much will the project cost?

Our Pro Remodeling contractors have the answers to these questions and more. To discuss your home renovation needs, give us a call at (520) 745-9769.